No Double Recovery

December 9, 2014

In a dispute between former business partners, the plaintiff sued the defendant for breach of contract, alleging that the defendant first agreed to reimburse him for certain expenses totaling $75,000, and then, second, when he refused to pay, promised the plaintiff that he would give him a check for $75,000 instead.  The jury found that the defendant breached both contracts and awarded the plaintiff $75,000 for each breach (for a total of $150,000).  Because that amounted to a double recovery, the Dallas Court of Appeals reversed and limited the plaintiff to one recovery of $75,000 for breach of contract.

Kim v. Pak