No Evidence

Brian Vodicka and Steven Aubrey provided nearly $1 million for a loan to fund a real estate development. The loan was only secured by a subordinate lien, and Vodicka and Aubrey lost their entire investment after the borrower defaulted. They sued North American Title, which had served as the escrow agent for the loan, alleging a variety of fraud, negligence, and fiduciary duty claims. The Court of Appeals affirmed summary judgment for the title company. The Court held that the trial court had not erred in striking the plaintiffs’ summary judgment evidence. The trial court had not abused its discretion in sustaining the defendant’s objection to a spreadsheet because the plaintiffs had failed to file it under seal as required by the court’s protective order. The plaintiffs also waived their complaint about their summary judgment affidavit because their appellate briefing failed to address several of the objections the defendant had asserted before the trial court. Those rulings meant that the plaintiffs were left with literally no evidence to respond to North American Title’s no-evidence motion, and the trial court’s grant of summary judgment was therefore affirmed.

Vodicka v. N. Am. Title Ins. Co., No. 05-13-00126-CV