Close Arbitration Call

The en banc Fifth Court divided 7-6 on a difficult arbitration issue; specifically, whether a court or the AAA should resolve arbitrability as to wrongful-death claims brought by estate representatives. Agreeing with the panel majority, the full-court majority  saw it as an issue for the AAA; the dissent, one for court. A concurrence urged consistency with applicable federal law. Prestonwood Tradition, LP v. Jennings, Nos. 05-20-00380 and -00387 et seq. (Aug. 5, 2022).

Justice Pedersen wrote the majority opinion, joined by Justices Myers, Schenck (who wrote a concurring opinion), Osborne, Reichek, Goldstein, and Smith. Justice Partida-Kipness wrote the dissent, joined by Chief Justice Burns and Justices Molberg, Nowell, Carlyle, and Garcia. The panel consisted of Justices Pedersen and Goldstein in the majority and Justice Partida-Kipness in dissent.