Unavailing Arbitration Challenge

The Fifth Court confirmed the confirmation of an arbitration award arising from a dispute about the purchase of a surgical center in Minimally Invasive Surgery Inst., LLC v. MISI Realty CC Dallas, LP. It reminded about two basic points in challenging arbitration awards:

• “‘Manifest disregard of the law‘ is not a valid ground for vacating an arbitration award under the FAA or TAA.”
• “[T]he Final Award notes the four-day arbitration included offers of proof, counsel statements, witness testimony, deposition and documentary evidence, and post-arbitration briefs. The arbitration award also states: ‘All issues have been determined by the evidence presented during the full arbitration.’ The award provides findings and conclusions with analysis. But the record contains little more than the arbitration award, the lease agreement, and the trial court order granting the motion to confirm the arbitration award. There is no list of exhibits or witnesses, no record of exhibits admitted into evidence or rulings on evidentiary objections, and no transcript of the proceedings. The trial court and appellate records do not include a complete record of the arbitration, and what is included is insufficient to allow this Court to conduct a meaningful review of any claimed ‘manifest disregard of the law’ by the arbitrator.”

No. 05-22-00581-CV (Oct. 19, 2023) (mem. op.) (emphasis added).